From the Shadows into the Light: How Pretrial Publicity and Deliberation Affect Mock Jurors’ Decisions, Impressions, and Memory
Document Type
Article
Publication Date
2015
Abstract
This 2-part study explored how exposure to negative pretrial publicity (Neg-PTP) influences the jury process, as well as possible mechanisms responsible for its biasing effects on decisions. Study Part A explored how PTP and jury deliberations affect juror/jury verdicts, memory, and impressions of the defendant and attorneys. One week before viewing a criminal trial mock-jurors (N = 320 university students) were exposed to Neg-PTP or unrelated crime stories (No-PTP). Two days later deliberating jurors came to a group decision, whereas nondeliberating jurors completed an unrelated task before making an individual decision. Neg-PTP jurors were more likely to vote guilty, make memory errors, and rate the defendant lower in credibility. Deliberation reduced Neg-PTP jurors’ memory accuracy and No-PTP jurors’ guilty verdicts (leniency bias). Jurors’ memory and ratings of the defendant and prosecuting attorney significantly mediated the effect of PTP on guilt ratings. Study Part B content analyzed 30 mock-jury deliberations and explored how PTP influenced deliberations and ultimately jury decisions. Neg-PTP juries were more likely than No-PTP juries to discuss ambiguous trial evidence in a proprosecution manner and less likely to discuss judicial instructions and lack of evidence. All Neg-PTP juries mentioned PTP, after instructed otherwise, and rarely corrected jury members who mentioned PTP. Discussion of ambiguous trial evidence in a proprosecution manner and lack of evidence significantly mediated the effect of PTP on jury-level guilt ratings. Together the findings suggest that judicial admonishments and deliberations may not be sufficient to reduce PTP bias, because of memory errors, biased impressions, and predecisional distortion.
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)
https://doi.org/10.1037/lhb0000117
Citation / Publisher Attribution
Law and Human Behavior, v. 39, issue 3, p. 294-310
Scholar Commons Citation
Ruva, Christine L. and Guenther, Christina C., "From the Shadows into the Light: How Pretrial Publicity and Deliberation Affect Mock Jurors’ Decisions, Impressions, and Memory" (2015). Psychology Sarasota Manatee Campus Faculty Publications. 12.
https://digitalcommons.usf.edu/psy_facpub_sm/12
Was this content written or created while at USF?
Yes
